PTC to Carl's Jr./Hardees:
Once Again, Paris Hilton Ad Doesn't Pay
(09.06.05) The PTC responded to the news that
the Paris Hilton television ad campaign did nothing to help Carl's Jr. and Hardee's profits for the year—in fact, the Associated Press has reported that
"sales at restaurants open at least a year were flat at Carl's Jr., while
Hardee's same-store sales fell 1 percent, well below last year's increases of
6.4 percent and 6.1 percent, respectively." In addition, Carl's Jr. stock price
has fallen approximately 30% since the Paris Hilton ad first aired.
"Once again we see the evidence that Carl's Jr. and Hardee's racy Paris Hilton
ad failed to increase sales. It's laughable that they continue to claim the ad
was a ‘success,' said L. Brent Bozell, president of the Parents Television
Council.
"The soft porn Paris Hilton ad has alienated millions of families and exposed
millions of children to raunchy content that has no place on television during
primetime hours.
"In corporate America today, there is a tragic mentality that corporate leaders
must choose between profit and integrity. This should be a clear lesson to other
companies: raunchy advertising just doesn't pay," concluded Bozell.
Guest Commentary:
Hamburger Porn
By Bill Saracino
"Despite the whirlwind of publicity generated by
its Paris Hilton ad, the controversial spot does not appear to have
significantly increased Carl's Jr. restaurant sales."
"Analysts and industry watchers were expecting
much higher returns in the wake of the worldwide attention paid to Carl's Jr.
and its Spicy Barbecue burger courtesy of Ms. Hilton's erotic car-washing
escapade in the ad."
At least one analyst has downgraded CKE shares
after the company reported lower-than-expected earnings yesterday despite higher
sales. Ad Age, 06/28/05
PTC Calls Paris Hilton Ad for Carl's Jr./Hardees Ultimate
Example of Corporate Irresponsibility
"This blatant sexually charged ad has no place on the public airwaves,
and especially when children are in the audience. Carl's Jr./Hardees
need to be held responsible for marketing their raunchy, sexually
graphic ad to millions of children via broadcast television and at
the Carl's Jr./Hardees' web sites without any restrictions," said
L. Brent Bozell, president of the PTC.
>> more
|